Chartered Accountants in India, working with clients across Europe

Section 143(2) Notice Response and Scrutiny Reply | NDSA
Section 143(2) · Scrutiny notice

Your return is under review. Here’s the reply plan.

A section 143(2) notice tells you your return has been selected for scrutiny. It is usually followed by detailed questions. Here is how each kind of question is usually answered.

3 monthsFrom the end of the year of filing
FacelessOnline replies
Section 270In the new Act
What they ask, what we sendTypical questions
Source of fundsWhere large amounts came fromTrailBank records and sale deeds
Capital gainsHow a gain was worked outWorkingCost, dates and exemptions
Cash depositsWhy cash was depositedExplanationSource with evidence
Foreign incomeWhy it isn’t taxed in IndiaStatusResidence proof and treaty position
DeductionsSupport for claims madeProofReceipts and certificates

The actual questions come in the notices that follow.

01 · Two notices

The notice and the questions that follow.

Section 143(2)Section 142(1)
PurposeStarts the scrutinyAsks for information
Time limitWithin 3 months from the end of the financial year of filingDuring the proceedings
New ActSection 270Section 268
Reply neededUsually a simple acknowledgementDetailed reply with evidence
02 · Common issues

Issues raised in NRI scrutiny.

Residential status

Whether you were really non-resident that year.

We provideTravel records, passport stamps and a residence certificate.
Watch forDays in India close to the limits.
Ask us about this
03 · Time limits

How the clock works.

  1. Filing

    Return filed

    For example in the 2025-26 financial year.

  2. Notice

    143(2) issued

    No later than 30 June 2026 for that example.

  3. Questions

    142(1) notices

    Each with its own reply date.

  4. Order

    Assessment completed

    Within the time limit set by law.

04 · How we help

What we do on a 143(2).

Read

Check the notice

Confirm it is valid and in time, and whether scrutiny is limited or complete.

Plan

Map the issues

List each issue and the evidence needed.

Draft

Write the reply

Clear, point-by-point submissions.

Submit

File online

Through e-proceedings, on time.

Follow

Stay to the order

Answer further questions and review the draft order.

05 · Examples

143(2) replies in practice.

MMeeraParis
Situation
Scrutiny of a large capital gain from selling inherited land.
What we did
Prepared the cost working with the inheritance documents and the reinvestment proof.
Outcome
Gain accepted as returned.
VVikramStockholm
Situation
Questions on his residential status in the year he moved abroad.
What we did
Provided travel records and his Swedish residence certificate.
Outcome
Non-resident status accepted.

Illustrative examples with names changed. Every case depends on its own facts.

Wherever you live in Europe

143(2) replies for clients across Europe.

We respond to scrutiny notices for clients in every EU country, Switzerland and Norway.

BerlinMunichFrankfurtHamburgStuttgartAmsterdamRotterdamThe HagueEindhovenBrusselsAntwerpLuxembourgParisLyonToulouseDublinCorkStockholmGothenburgCopenhagenHelsinkiOsloZurichGenevaViennaMilanRomeMadridBarcelonaLisbonPortoWarsawKrakówPragueBudapestBucharestTallinnVilniusAthensValletta
06 · FAQs

Section 143(2) questions answered.

What is a 143(2) notice?
A notice that your return is selected for scrutiny.
Is there a time limit for it?
Yes, three months from the end of the financial year of filing.
What if it came late?
A notice issued out of time can be challenged.
What should I reply?
Usually an acknowledgement, then detailed replies to later questions.
What is a 142(1) notice?
A notice asking for information during the scrutiny.
Which section applies now?
Section 270 of the new Act; earlier years use 143(2).
Is it faceless?
Yes, in most cases.
Do I need to visit India?
No.
What if I miss a reply date?
Request more time quickly; otherwise an order may follow.
Can you handle it for me?
Yes, as your authorised representative.

Got a 143(2) notice? Start the reply plan now.

Send us the notice and your return. We’ll check it and map out the reply.

General guidance based on the rules as they stand, including the Income-tax Act, 2025 and the Income-tax Rules, 2026. It is not legal, tax or financial advice for your situation; please contact us before acting on it.